Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

[Firaeon]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

most of the FFXI-playing vocal haters of WoW sucked so badly they never made it to max level and ended up experiencing the sheer crushing demand on your time that is endgame in WoW.

Do you have an actual source for that? That's kind of a big assumption that most people who play FFXI that don't like WoW suck.

[Grizzlebeard]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

Inconceivable!

The sad thing is, most of the FFXI-playing vocal haters of WoW sucked so badly they never made it to max level and ended up experiencing the sheer crushing demand on your time that is endgame in WoW. The tactics to beat the bosses in one zone in WoW shame the strategies required for every single HNM in FFXI. Now, I myself grew tired of the timesink of reputation grinding, material farming, and endgame raiding in WoW so I'm by no means attempting to champion the game. I just find it highly ironic when people claim the game is weaksauce and then go on to mention they failed to make it to max level and yet somehow feel their uneducated blanket statements are going to be met with anything short of derision.

[Firaeon]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

and are basing this feeling on what you'd like to be the case as opposed to what is really going on.

I'm basing this feeling from what I've experienced personally. Don't shove words into my mouth. I'm done debating on this because you're basically saying I don't know jack shit because I'm a new player. I read up on the game, and I play the game. I'm even comparing both of my beginning experiences from the games. I'm enjoying my beginning experience on FFXI more than I enjoyed it on WoW.

EDIT: I even enjoyed Knight Online more than I enjoyed WoW.

[Murphie]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

Well, on the perspective of "If you had to choose one". Yeah, you can like both.

But you don't have to choose one. No one does. Especially not in the context of this thread, because WoW has a free trial.

You have to admit that you need to devote more time to FFXI than WoW a day. I don't know about some people, but me + more time on something = better feeling of accomplishment.

I don't have to admit anything. More time on something doesn't necessarily increase my sense of accomplishment. And I spent a heck of a lot more time per day playing WoW than I do playing FFXI, but that's me.

Which is my point. No factions = less hatred, which usually builds a better community.

You can't hear what the other side has to say in WoW anyway. So what are you talking about exactly?

And there is plenty of stupidity and mean spirited people in this game as well. I'm just saying.

Statistical: of, pertaining to, consisting of, or based on statistics.

I see a lot more numbers in FFXI. Theres a lot of stats involved to build an ideal character in FFXI. WoW relies on stats of course, but I feel that it's a lot more exploited, I guess, in FFXI.

Of course, your experience in FFXI amounts to about a week, so you really don't know, and are basing this feeling on what you'd like to be the case as opposed to what is really going on.

[jwalton]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

It'd really take a lot of heat off equipment debates and people in general. Who knows if it would actually work any better though.

Heh, sadly... I'd say it'd probably make things worse as far as the fighting goes. Even if it did resolve such debates, people would just focus on another subject to yell at each other about.

[Firaeon]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

Or you like both, and don't fit into two tiny little boxes. Because the world doesn't work that way anyhow.

Well, on the perspective of "If you had to choose one". Yeah, you can like both.

That's entirely subjective. Just because you didn't like WoW, and you like FFXI right now, doesn't really mean anything except that you didn't like WoW and you like FFXI right now.

You have to admit that you need to devote more time to FFXI than WoW a day. I don't know about some people, but me + more time on something = better feeling of accomplishment.

There is less hatred between factions because there aren't any factions in FFXI.

Which is my point. No factions = less hatred, which usually builds a better community.

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

Statistical: of, pertaining to, consisting of, or based on statistics.

I see a lot more numbers in FFXI. Theres a lot of stats involved to build an ideal character in FFXI. WoW relies on stats of course, but I feel that it's a lot more exploited, I guess, in FFXI.

[Murphie]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

I'll just say this: it's personal preference. You either like FFXI, or you like WoW.

Or you like both, and don't fit into two tiny little boxes. Because the world doesn't work that way anyhow.

and more simplified crafting system (however I haven't tried the FFXI crafting system yet, it seems more detailed from what I've researched).

I guess. If by "more detailed" you mean "unnecessarily frustrating, and devoid of logic," then sure. I don't personally regard FFXI or WoW's Crafting models as any sort of ideal.

FFXI is for people who have more time to do things and thus I believe you get more of a feeling of accomplishment.

That's entirely subjective. Just because you didn't like WoW, and you like FFXI right now, doesn't really mean anything except that you didn't like WoW and you like FFXI right now.

There's also less hatred between factions/races. In WoW, you have morons running around saying "lol HORD IS TEH WINZ" or "Horde sucks ass Alliance is way better!". And from when I PvP'd a little on there, people get too into it really. They're acting like it's before Black Rights in America, and they're killing each other with actual hatred. Really weird. There also seems to be more WoW 'nerds', and 'nerds', in the definition of 'completely obsessed and obnoxious with the game' are NOT a good thing to have in a game really.

There is less hatred between factions because there aren't any factions in FFXI. The faction system is at the core of WoW's mythos though, so yeah, kind of prominent.

Sorry, but from playing, I personally believe it's more statistical than WoW.

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

[DakAttack]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

In World of Warcraft you are what you're wearing, and I believe that's because they do tell you every little thing about what you're wearing. I think FFXI is a little too specific as well. I'd like to see the equipment be descrbed as "Enhances Strength" or "Enhances Accuracy", rather than Attack+# or Accuracy+#. It'd really take a lot of heat off equipment debates and people in general. Who knows if it would actually work any better though.

[Firaeon]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

If by statistical, you mean vague, then you'd be correct. World of Warcraft gives all the information you need at your fingertips. Final Fantasy XI keeps everything hidden and some people consider this "depth" because it's "more challenging" and therefore equates to it somehow being a better game. Then they rush to Allakhazam to get the latest guide on how to beat Obscure Quest X and what CHR does or doesn't do for Paladin.

Don't get me wrong... World of Warcraft wasn't my thing either. But you're not being objective here at all. World of Warcraft's mechanics are deeper than Final Fantasy XI's. Usually someone will rush in the game's defense and reference skillchains, but just about everyone plays TP burn parties these days so that's kind of moot anymore. Besides, skillchains are neat, but really not that big a deal. I mean, combining skills/spells for extra damage was done as far back as Phantasy Star IV on the Sega Genesis back in 1993. Granted, it's not an online game, but the concept isn't exactly "WOW" by any means. It was possible to combine photon blasts in Phantasy Star Online, but that didn't make it any less shallow of a game.

I guess "vague" could be correct. I like to figure things out sometimes, it makes games interesting.

[jwalton]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

Sorry, but from playing, I personally believe it's more statistical than WoW.

If by statistical, you mean vague, then you'd be correct. World of Warcraft gives all the information you need at your fingertips. Final Fantasy XI keeps everything hidden and some people consider this "depth" because it's "more challenging" and therefore equates to it somehow being a better game. Then they rush to Allakhazam to get the latest guide on how to beat Obscure Quest X and what CHR does or doesn't do for Paladin.

Don't get me wrong... World of Warcraft wasn't my thing either. But you're not being objective here at all. World of Warcraft's mechanics are deeper than Final Fantasy XI's. Usually someone will rush in the game's defense and reference skillchains, but just about everyone plays TP burn parties these days so that's kind of moot anymore. Besides, skillchains are neat, but really not that big a deal. I mean, combining skills/spells for extra damage was done as far back as Phantasy Star IV on the Sega Genesis back in 1993. Granted, it's not an online game, but the concept isn't exactly "WOW" by any means. It was possible to combine photon blasts in Phantasy Star Online, but that didn't make it any less shallow of a game.

[little ninja]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

Well, I'm comparing them from when I started. Like, when I started WoW, I had less to do than on FFXI when I started. I've also read up on stuff too, and I like the idea of having one character to be able to try and master ALL the jobs on. It just works better for me, I guess. WoW really has less feeling of accomplishment too. Even when I started FFXI, I felt accomplished when I sold some stuff at the AH. I never really felt that before in WoW.
I'll just say this: it's personal preference. You either like FFXI, or you like WoW. WoW is for people who like a simple MMORPG where you can go through dungeon runs and grind and more simplified crafting system (however I haven't tried the FFXI crafting system yet, it seems more detailed from what I've researched). FFXI is for people who have more time to do things and thus I believe you get more of a feeling of accomplishment. There's also less hatred between factions/races. In WoW, you have morons running around saying "lol HORD IS TEH WINZ" or "Horde sucks ass Alliance is way better!". And from when I PvP'd a little on there, people get too into it really. They're acting like it's before Black Rights in America, and they're killing each other with actual hatred. Really weird. There also seems to be more WoW 'nerds', and 'nerds', in the definition of 'completely obsessed and obnoxious with the game' are NOT a good thing to have in a game really.
Sorry, but from playing, I personally believe it's more statistical than WoW.

WoW = factions hating each other. An FFXI = Ls's hating each other. This is something you can neither grasp or understand sitting in a starting nation with a job not even into the teens. Both games have the satisfaction of accomplishment. You just never gave WoW the chance for it to happen. As for FFXI, you have yet to sit thru insane amount of hours expless. Stuck on an AF, stuck on a mission, or stuck on a cap quest because you can neither find the appropriate jobs to help you out.

This game offers very little in strategy. You will end up in the course of your FFXI life fighting similar type of mob 86% of the time. You fight the same mobs, with the same jobs, with the same skill chain, with the same magic burst. The same could be said for every part of FFXI as well as Wow.

[Firaeon]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

You've been playing it for less than a week. I don't think you're able to really objectively compare the two.

Well, I'm comparing them from when I started. Like, when I started WoW, I had less to do than on FFXI when I started. I've also read up on stuff too, and I like the idea of having one character to be able to try and master ALL the jobs on. It just works better for me, I guess. WoW really has less feeling of accomplishment too. Even when I started FFXI, I felt accomplished when I sold some stuff at the AH. I never really felt that before in WoW.

I'll just say this: it's personal preference. You either like FFXI, or you like WoW. WoW is for people who like a simple MMORPG where you can go through dungeon runs and grind and more simplified crafting system (however I haven't tried the FFXI crafting system yet, it seems more detailed from what I've researched). FFXI is for people who have more time to do things and thus I believe you get more of a feeling of accomplishment. There's also less hatred between factions/races. In WoW, you have morons running around saying "lol HORD IS TEH WINZ" or "Horde sucks ass Alliance is way better!". And from when I PvP'd a little on there, people get too into it really. They're acting like it's before Black Rights in America, and they're killing each other with actual hatred. Really weird. There also seems to be more WoW 'nerds', and 'nerds', in the definition of 'completely obsessed and obnoxious with the game' are NOT a good thing to have in a game really.

But I also like the fact that FFXI is more complicated and, I guess, strategy oriented.

Sorry, but from playing, I personally believe it's more statistical than WoW.

[Grizzlebeard]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

But I also like the fact that FFXI is more complicated and, I guess, strategy oriented.

You guess wrong.

[Murphie]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

You've been playing it for less than a week. I don't think you're able to really objectively compare the two.

[Firaeon]

Re: Ugh. Someone talk me out of it.

FFXI is more exciting to me because theres far more to do and experiment with. It may also help that I'm a Final Fantasy Fan all around, so I like the atmosphere better. But I also like the fact that FFXI is more complicated and, I guess, strategy oriented.