Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

? Performance: Pentium vs. AMD ?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • ? Performance: Pentium vs. AMD ?

    Hiyas.

    I'm going to be upgrading my system soon, and want to configure it for top performance in FFXI. You know that program Fraps? ...well, as of now the playback is extremely crappy. So, which would you recommend for supreme recording quality in Fraps? I know AMD is faster, but Pentium is more powerful. I am looking at either a P4-2.6Ghz, or an AMD Athlon XP 3000+. Please post suggestions on which I should go with for optimum system performance when recording videos in Fraps. Thanks.

    www.rta.ssxh.net/ffxi
    -=[ 24 WAR ]=-=[ 05 THF ]=-
    Soon to be Paladin.

  • #2
    p4 vs athlon

    Acutally the Athlon 3000 is only a 2.1 GigHa processor so based on pure proccessor speed the P4 is faster....but the Athlon chips are more efficient so they dont have to be as fast......from my experiece...they best thing to have to play games effectivly is plenty of memory ( i use 512 DDR for my athlon ) and a good video card ( 256 MB FX 5600 ) my processor is the Athlon 1800+ ( 1.5 Ghz) and i run this game on highest specs.......one thing you might want to look at between the 2..which processor is better money wise............hope this helps

    Comment


    • #3
      out of a 2.6 ghz P4 and a 3000+ Athlon you should definately choose the Athlon. Also go for a Radeon 9600 Pro (which should be available for around $150) and dual channel DDR 400 memory (two identical sticks of 256 mb) and a motherboard with an nForce 2 ultra 400 chipset.

      just my 2 cents... or rather $450

      characters (7th of June 2005):
      "Julio" Hume/male; Rank 5
      Lvl 50 WHM (Lvl 45 THF, Lvl 31 BLM, Lvl 24 NIN, Lvl 18 WAR, Lvl 9 RDM; Lvl 9 RNG, Lvl 9 MNK); Bastok; Siren server

      "Lauryn" Mithra/female; Rank 1
      Lvl 9 WAR (Lvl 8 THF); Windhurst; Siren server

      "Constance" Hume/female; Rank 1
      Lvl 16 MNK; San d'Oria; Siren server

      "Quinten" Taru Taru/male; Rank 1
      Lvl 9 MNK, Lvl 8 THF, Lvl 8 WAR, Lvl 1 BLM; Bastok; Siren server
      -------
      email

      Comment


      • #4
        *bump*


        Out of you people who use Fraps, and get *quality* video feed, what processors are you using?

        www.rta.ssxh.net/ffxi
        -=[ 24 WAR ]=-=[ 05 THF ]=-
        Soon to be Paladin.

        Comment


        • #5
          Hell I use fraps and all I use for a processor is a AMD 2100. I get great quality i believe im gonna be making video's soon once I buy the program.
          SilverMatrix -
          level 75BRD/70THF/55BLM/37WHM/15war/37NIN/10DRK/10BST
          Race: Taru
          Server:Odin
          Linkshell: A New Dawn, Decimation

          Comment


          • #6
            Hehe, using Fraps with a 1.3 Duron is not good (long story :sweat: ). The Athlon XP 3000+ will save you lots of $$$$$ (might as well spend the extra on more RAM, face it, everyone needs more RAM ).

            Comment


            • #7
              y the hell would you buy a 3000+?
              i o/c'd my 2200+ to 3200+...
              with a decent cooling system good heatsink and good thermal paste you won't even run hot...




              75MNK, 62BRD , 37WAR , 37THF, 37WHM

              Full AF "Paragon of Monk Excellence"
              Genkei 5 Completed
              Rank 10 San, Rank 8 Windy, Rank1 Bastok
              Zilart and CoP Missions Complete
              93 Merrits, slacking need to work on that..
              Shura Haidate +1, body and head.
              Faith Torque, Black Belt , 3/5 Tu'lia Set, 4/5 AF2, 1/5 AF+1

              Comment


              • #8
                YEah im gonna go with whatever motherboard/cpu combo i can get cheapest.. (around $200-250) ...ill prolly end up with an overclocked amd, but I'm tired of thinking about it so I'm gonna go pick one out. Thanks for all the input.


                .Zorbaine.

                www.rta.ssxh.net/ffxi
                -=[ 24 WAR ]=-=[ 05 THF ]=-
                Soon to be Paladin.

                Comment


                • #9
                  couple of things...

                  1. AMD is gonna be the best Value/Performence ratio hands down

                  2. That said go for a mobo that uses a north bridge NForce2 Ultra 400 and a southbridge MCP-T. It isn't all about JUST processors motherboards are probably a bigger factor.

                  3. People say 512 megs of ram is awsome but honestly Windows XP is a hog and while you can get fine performence with 512 I would recomend 1gig of Dual channel because of the FRAPS

                  4. Furthermore, slow downs can be caused by hard drives these days too for what it seems like you want to do I would recomend to get a motherboard that supports Serial ATA harddives and then get one! Possibly a 10k rpm if you have the cash.

                  5. In the end theres SO many more factors then JUST processors and I honestly recomend you research exactly what you are buying before you buy it...A few things you might want to understand

                  What a northbridge, southbridge does, and how the ram works (dual channel really!). Oh and what a FSB does too.

                  Read up on the difference between ATA, Serial ATA, raid drives, and SCSI.

                  Learn all you can about the video cards such as how many pixel pipelines affect your performence, the speeds of ram, 128bit vs 256bit processors etc etc

                  I really could write pages and pages about this stuff but I would have a headache and would have to research some stuff because I like to speak with evidence to back it up so I won't. In the end if you are going to spend $200-500 of your money why not understand fully what you are getting. It dosn't take too much work you just need a couple good places too start.

                  For looking at different parts I prefer www.newegg.com
                  For detailed explanations of equipment www.tomshardware.com does expalin how some of the hardware interacts with each other.

                  just my 2 cents

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Thanks alot, I'll do just that... gonna rack up a bit more cash first though.

                    www.rta.ssxh.net/ffxi
                    -=[ 24 WAR ]=-=[ 05 THF ]=-
                    Soon to be Paladin.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      I use Fraps fine with my Athlon 2100+ system, and about the same on my Dual P4 Xeon 2.4@3.0 system.

                      Fraps strips the data directy from directx, hence now the game is essentially loading 'twice'. The only way to get Fraps running better, is to reduce your screen resolution (the first res. setting in the config) to no higher than 1024x768. I find this makes a world of difference when I'm recording.

                      My system specs:

                      System1:
                      ABit NF7-S
                      Athlon2100+ @1.83 on w/ Thermaltake Volcano 11+ Cooling
                      1GB Crucial PC2100 DDR
                      PowerColor Radeon9600PRO 256mb

                      System2:
                      Intel SE7500CW2ATA Motherboard w/ Swiftech Northbridge Block
                      Dual P4-533 Xeon 2.4@3.0s on Swiftech Water Blocks
                      1GB Corsair PC2100 DDR
                      Built-by ATI Radeon All-in-Wonder 9800 128mb w/ Swiftech GFX Waterblock

                      Fraps is a memory hog, both systems chop up a little bit even at low resolutions.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Okay, I've narrowed the video card down to 2 choices... and would like to know which would run FFXI better. Please post suggestions:


                        Choice 1 :: eVGA GeForceFX 5900se 128MB DDR AGP8X with TV-Out & DVI Video Card


                        Choice 2 :: Sapphire Radeon 9800se 128MB AGP8X with TV & DVI Video Card



                        -Aside from these, I was considering the ATI Radeon 9700Pro, any suggestions?

                        www.rta.ssxh.net/ffxi
                        -=[ 24 WAR ]=-=[ 05 THF ]=-
                        Soon to be Paladin.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Well, I know you're asking about which will run FFXI better, but I'm gonna assume you're going to want to play other games eventually lol. If that's the case, go for the 9800. But I don't think getting an SE is a very good thing to do personally. I don't remember exactly how it's worse (I think they haved the bit rate on 'em) but well, it's worse. And don't buy from there lol. It's $40 more expensive than if you bought it (the 9800SE) there than if you bought it at www.newegg.com Here is the link to the Video Card page specifically: http://www.newegg.com/app/manufactor...alog=48&DEPA=1 It's a great site w/ very good service.

                          So if you just want to play FFXI (which seems like an awfully large amount of money just for this game) then it doesn't matter, either will do quite nicely. But if you want future use get another card IMO. I suggest the Radeon 9600 XT if you want to stay in the same price range (do not get an nVidia card if u want later use out of it haha). OR if you want to spend some more, just fork out the money for the 9800 Pro. Hope this helped.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I'm not entirely sure but I think that the 9800 SE has 4 pixel pipelines as opposed to 8 (9800 pro, 9800 NP) The one you're looking at the picture is of a NP box and not an SE box. If it is IN FACT a NP from Sapphire then it will be overclockable to the 9800 pro specs with a bios flash and no additional cooling. I would stick with ATI either way. nVidia's are loud is the main reason. They have like jet engine exhausts fans. You can't really count FPS because above 60 your eye can't tell the difference and I'm pretty sure FFXI forces 30 FPS anyways. Not to mention the picture quality and colors is superior in ATI's over nVidia's.
                            I don't know half of you half as well as I should like, and I like less than half of you half as well as you deserve. -JRR Tolkein

                            Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than open it and remove all doubt. - Mark Twain

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            X