Originally posted by cidbahamut
View Post
I say its thematically faithful in that the Witchblade is just a total enigma like it was in the early years of the comic. I only followed the early years so the Witchblade having a mind of its own and corporations warring over it is familiar territory from the comic. Plus the Witchblade doesn't dominate every episode, so which is also rather consistent with the comic, so there's lots of room to develop the heroine and the cast much like the comics did.
It goes its own way with the main character, her daughter Ryoko and other relationships though, and so for those unfamiliar with the comic, that's a fair trade off. For fans of the comic, it just keeps things fresh. It doesn't hurt that most of the cast is incredibly likable.
Its a nice adaptation, to say the least, though I'm sure it still would ruffle the feathers of purists for not being as dark and bloody as the comics. Then again, the live action TV show probably pissed people off as well. I haven't seen the short-live live action show, though.
My only complaints were that Masane's proportions sometimes too fanservicey, sometimes even distracting from what would otherwise be a really emotional scene. I mean, seriously, I know we're trying to have a serious moment, that social services is trying to take your daughter away here but.... dat ass! Then again, the comics were somewhat guilty of this as well.
The other problem is while all the people on the good side of things get a lot of development, there's just not enough time to really develop the villains save for a few. There are a couple of awesome baddies that just never really go anywhere or die before you learn anything about them. So you get like three of four Boba Fetts here. So just know they're evil and they had it coming.
The family drama is really the heart of the show and what makes it worth watching, though. It does a fantastic job of expressing what it wants to there.



Leave a comment: