Thank you for your input guys, along the same lines as what I was thinking but it's good to have more than one viewpoint.
I was eating meat with both the setups, and as /NIN (unless there was a bard/corsair) I noticed that my acc was good, but not as high as I liked... (I don't use parsers so I go mainly from observation. I know it's nowhere near as reliable, but I just don't like using 3rd-party tools all that much.)
So I thought perhaps I could switch to +atk gear and eat sushi, see what happens.
LS member has a Byrnie lying around unused (semi-retired his Warrior long time ago but kept the Byrnie) so I'll be borrowing that for a while, try it out for free
